An Open Letter to Josh Shapiro Asking Him to Reject School Vouchers 

An Open Letter to Josh Shapiro Asking Him to Reject School Vouchers 


Dear Josh Shapiro, 

Are you for general public training or not?

I only request since as the Democratic applicant for Governor in Pennsylvania, you occur off as the savior of educational institutions and kids on the marketing campaign path.

You say you want to boost condition funding to public faculties. Amazing!

You say you want to decrease standardized screening. Excellent!

You want to assure just about every college student has access to specialized and vocational classes and make absolutely sure each individual faculty developing has at the very least one particular devoted psychological well being counselor on team. Outstanding!

But in interviews and on your marketing campaign Web site, you say you are in favor of school vouchers!


Did Charles Koch just hack your election headquarters? Is Betsy DeVos impersonating you in the media?

Since supporting university vouchers does not healthy in at all with someone who promises to winner community education and learning.

General public schooling indicates community colleges. It means tax pounds becoming utilised to fund community universities and those faculties becoming operate by elected faculty boards.

It does not indicate tax bucks likely to personal and parochial colleges. It does not imply our income going to institutions exactly where we get no say in how it is expended. It does not suggest circumventing duly elected faculty boards. It does not suggest the community spending for spiritual indoctrination or the variety of suitable wing biased training routinely presented at private faculties.

But which is what faculty vouchers do.

They steal taxpayer pounds from reliable general public universities and let them to be squandered on private and parochial educational facilities. They destroy any accountability for how our collective revenue is expended and do major harm to hundreds of the most having difficulties authentic community university college students when lining the pockets of non-public companies and religious establishments.

And the separation of church and point out – forget about it!

This does not audio like the candidate lecturers like me have been backing considering the fact that ahead of this election cycle commenced. Frankly, it is virtually what your gubernatorial opponent, MAGA Republican Doug Mastriano, champions.

Mastriano – a Trump insurrectionist – suggests he needs to use condition schooling funding to give Each and every pupil a school voucher they can use at almost any college in the Commonwealth – public, private or parochial.

You look to want vouchers ONLY for pupils at the most underfunded and struggling universities.

Effectively which is some difference!

Rather of offering much more aid to the most inequitably funded faculties, you want to slash their funding even additional in the name of some aged time Republican program to allow a several escape a undesirable scenario though the rest all drown!?

That is repulsive!

On your your campaign Site it states

 Josh favors introducing choices for mother and father and academic opportunity for pupils and funding lifeline scholarships like individuals permitted in other states and released in Pennsylvania. 

In an job interview in the Patriot Information you say

 “And I’m for generating certain we incorporate scholarships like lifeline scholarships to make guaranteed that that is additive to their instruction. That it presents them other opportunities…to be able to aid them attain success”  

These so-termed Lifeline Scholarships are a Republican guide evaluate to give immediate-to-college student tax-funded scholarships that mom and dad and guardians in the state’s most neglected general public faculties could use for a variety of alternatives together with heading towards tuition at a different school.

The GOP sponsored monthly bill passed the condition House of Associates in April on a 104-98 vote and cleared the condition Senate Instruction Committee in June. Nonetheless, because of an modification to shield lower executing constitution universities from dropping their funding, it would nevertheless need to have last passage votes in each chambers ahead of obtaining to existing Gov. Tom Wolf’s desk the place he would nearly absolutely veto it.

It would have an affect on about 191,000 learners in 382 educational institutions, across 76 of the state’s 500 university districts. Having said that, Two-thirds of the charge of the software (63.1%) is born by 4 districts – Philadelphia (43.9%), Studying (8.9%), Allentown (5.8%) and Pittsburgh (4.5%).

This would build yet another taxpayer funded system of schooling. Impacted districts would get rid of so considerably funding it would in the end pressure them to decrease programs, services, and staffing and/or raise property taxes to compensate.

Furthermore, these would be the most neglected districts, and thus the least in a position to aid the charge.

It is a horrible concept, and I simply cannot comprehend why you would buck the overwhelming the greater part of your occasion and would-be constituents to assist it.

Is it for the reason that you ship your very own little ones to a faith-based mostly personal college, and that you are the products of just this kind of an instruction, on your own?

This is how you drop votes, Sir.

Your opponent is maybe the most odious individual to at any time operate for Governor in the state. He seems to usher in an period of theocratic fascism, curtail human rights and choose the Commonwealth back to the Middle Ages.

But that doesn’t mean you should really operate closer to his positions in the vain hope of thieving some of his foundation.

The MAGA Republicans will never vote for you. Dressing you up in their clothing will not help you do anything at all but disgust your have supporters until some just cannot deliver by themselves to vote at all.

As election working day nears, the polls get nearer and closer between Mastriano and you.

Pennsylvanians just can’t find the money for losing their only possibility at self rule because of demoralization and despair at a prospect much too weak to guidance the platform he started this campaign on – championing general public schooling.

I urge you to rethink this flirtation with Republican values and university vouchers.

I hope you are better than this.

We are worthy of a governor who is far better than this.

Be sure to have the courage to stand by genuine general public colleges.


Steven Singer

Like this put up?  You could want to contemplate becoming a Patreon subscriber. This will help me continue to preserve the web site heading and get on with this tricky and tough operate.

Plus you get subscriber only extras!

Just Simply click Right here.


I’ve also composed a e-book, “Gadfly on the Wall: A Public College Trainer Speaks Out on Racism and Reform,” now out there from Garn Push. 10 p.c of the proceeds go to the Badass Instructors Association. Examine it out!

Leave a Reply